Descartes Index 20 ranks #60 among 122 3a investment funds in Switzerland. It's a passive Swisscanto strategy with 20% equity, 65% bonds, 10% Swiss real estate, 4% gold and 1% money market, held in a personal securities account at Lienhardt & Partner Privatbank Zürich. A very defensive allocation aimed at investors within a few years of withdrawal.
Are You Paying 0.62% for a Bond-Heavy 3a?
All-in cost is 0.62% (0.22% weighted TER plus 0.40% flat fee). On CHF 50'000 that's CHF 310 per year. With only 20% in stocks, that fee is a real drag: a bond-heavy mix has a lower expected return than an equity strategy, yet you pay almost the same price as Descartes' 99% equity version.
The returns show the trade-off. Over 3 years the strategy made +15.89%, but over 5 years only +7.36%. The longer window includes 2022, when bonds and stocks fell together, and Descartes' own factsheet shows the model portfolio down 12.97% that year. The latest 1-year figure is +1.85%.
What Actually Stands Out
The defensive part is real bonds, not cash. 47% goes into a Swisscanto index fund of Swiss CHF bonds rated AAA to BBB, 10% into world government bonds and 8% into global corporate bonds, both hedged back to CHF. Descartes says openly on its 3a page that it prefers bonds over cash.
The rest is diversifiers plus a small equity core, all built from Swisscanto index funds: 10% Swiss indirect real estate, 4% physical gold, 15% Swiss equities, 3.75% world ex-Switzerland equities and 1.25% CHF-hedged world equities. There's no emerging markets fund at this risk level, and money market is just 1%.
What Most Reviews Miss
Bonds bring interest-rate risk. When rates rise, bond prices fall, and listed Swiss real estate funds are rate-sensitive too. That's exactly what 2022 looked like. If you need this money in 1-3 years and can't stomach a dip, a 3a savings account has no price risk at all, which this strategy can't promise.
Two details from the factsheet. Your fund units sit at Lienhardt & Partner Privatbank Zürich in your own name, but they can't be transferred out in kind, so switching provider means selling first. And Descartes can replace the underlying funds at any time for objective reasons, so the line-up above is a snapshot, not a contract.
The Bottom Line
Descartes Index 20 is a genuine conservative multi-asset mix, not a cash parking spot. It makes sense if you want bonds, Swiss real estate and gold doing most of the work with a small equity kicker, and you value a private-bank depot. Weigh it against the alternatives in our guide to the best 3a investment funds in Switzerland.
Verdict: A properly diversified defensive 3a, but the 0.62% fee eats a big share of a bond-heavy return.