frankly Moderate 45 Sustainable ranks #117 among 201 3a investment funds in Switzerland, behind its Responsible and Index siblings. It's an actively managed Swisscanto fund with 45% stocks and strict SDG screening. It makes sense if sustainability rules are your priority. If returns are, read on.
How Does the Return Stack Up?
Over three years to 30 September 2026, the fund returned +24.54% after fees, or about 7.6% a year. frankly's Moderate 45 Index made +28.36% over the same stretch, and Responsible +24.35%. Over one year it's +8.19%, between the Index (+9.47%) and Responsible (+7.96%) versions.
Among funds with 30% to 60% stocks that have a three-year record, it lands just below the middle. Neon Balanced 45 Sustainable (0.42%) made +29.31% and VIAC Global Sustainable 40 (0.26%) +27.73%.
What Actually Stands Out
The cost is the real strength. At 0.43% all-in, charged only on the invested part, it's 0.05 points cheaper than frankly's other two 45% funds, and there are no issuing or redemption fees. On CHF 50'000 that's about CHF 215 a year.
The sustainability rules are the other reason to pick it. The Swisscanto BVG 3 fund aims to reduce CO2 intensity by at least 7.5% a year and excludes more than the Responsible line. If that matters to you, you can check the holdings on the Swisscanto product page.
What Most Reviews Miss
Cheaper doesn't always mean higher ranked. Swissquote 3a Balanced costs 0.60% yet ranks higher, because it has a five-year record and a better three-year return (+26.95%). This fund only has three years of data, so its performance score is capped and it earns 2 of 5 track-record points.
The 3.8-point gap to frankly's own Index version over three years is worth noticing. On a CHF 50'000 balance, that's roughly CHF 1'900 less. Active sustainable management hasn't paid off in this risk band so far.
The Bottom Line
Pick it for the sustainability rules and the low fee, not for the returns. If you want ESG and a stronger record in a balanced fund, the Neon and VIAC sustainable options deserve a look. Our guide to sustainable 3a funds explains how the different ESG labels compare.
Verdict: A cheap, strictly sustainable balanced fund whose returns so far trail frankly's Index version and most of its peers.