Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG

70% bonds, 20% stocks and a 0.71% total cost. On a low-return mix, that fee bites hard.

Overall Rating
3.2/5
Ranked #140 of 201View Top 10
  • Investment Fund (3a)
Adrien Missioux
Written by Adrien Missioux
Last updated on Swiss Made
Pilla
Total Costs
0.71%
Stocks
20%
Investment Strategy
Passively-managed fund
Best For:
cautious savers within a few years of withdrawal, investors who want a bond-heavy ESG portfolio in an app, Pilla users who want a defensive pot alongside a growth portfolio
Consider Alternatives If:
you want a low-risk 3a under 0.40% total cost, a 3a savings account would meet your needs, you need five years of real returns to judge a strategy
On This Page

Our Take on Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG

Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG ranks #140 among 201 3a investment funds in Switzerland. It's Pilla's most defensive strategy: 20% stocks, 70% bonds, 5% real estate and 5% other assets, all in ESG index funds. It's for cautious savers who want a bond-heavy portfolio in an app and accept a fee that takes a big share of the return.

Are the Fees Worth It?

Pilla's 0.50% fee plus a 0.21% fund TER makes 0.71% a year. Over three years to 30 September 2026, the strategy returned 15.77% net, or 5.00% a year, so the fee took roughly one-eighth of the gross return. VIAC Global Sustainable 20 costs 0.16% and returned 18.43% over the same three years.

On CHF 40'000, 0.71% is CHF 284 a year, against CHF 64 at VIAC Global Sustainable 20 and CHF 200 at Yuh 3a Mild. In our scoring, the cost earns 23.4 of 40 points. Performance was mid-table among funds with up to 30% stocks.

What Actually Stands Out

It's the most bond-heavy strategy in the Pilla range, with 70% in bonds. For someone a few years from withdrawal, that's a deliberate choice to limit equity swings while staying invested. The funds come from UBS, Swisscanto, Vanguard and iShares, all ESG index products.

The bank is Crédit Agricole next bank (Suisse) SA in Geneva, and the pension foundation is the Liberty 3a foundation in Schwyz. Pilla's pillar 3a page lists the strategies. You can hold up to five portfolios, so a defensive pot can sit next to a growth one.

What Most Reviews Miss

Bonds don't guarantee calm. The three-year window to September 2026 starts after the 2022 bond sell-off, so our data hasn't captured how this mix behaves when interest rates jump. A 70% bond portfolio can still lose money in a year like that.

There's also no five-year record, so our methodology gives 2 of 5 track-record points and caps performance at 85% of 45. Its mid-table result keeps it well below the cap. Over the last 12 months it returned just 2.29% net, which shows how thin the margin gets in a quiet year.

The Bottom Line

Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG does what a defensive 3a should, but at a price that's hard to justify for a low-return strategy. It fits if you're set on Pilla's app and want a bond-heavy pot. Getting close to withdrawal? Our guide to 3a near retirement covers the timing questions.

Verdict: A cautious, bond-heavy ESG 3a whose fee takes too large a share of a modest return.

Pros
  • No custody fee
Cons
  • Limited track record (no 5-year data)
  • No swing pricing protection

Product Details

  • 20% stocks allocation
  • TER: 0.21%
  • Passive/Index strategy
  • No custody fee

Fund Details

Investment Strategy
Passively-managed fund
Depositary Bank
Crédit Agricole next bank (Suisse) SA
Swing Pricing
No

Fees & Costs

TER
0.21%
Flat Fee
0.50%
Custody Fee
Free

Asset Allocation

How this fund splits your 3a money across asset classes, as published by the provider.

Stocks 20%Bonds 70%Real Estate 5%Other 5%
20%Stocks
  • Stocks20%
  • Bonds70%
  • Real Estate5%
  • Other5%

Performance Over Time

Historical performance of this investment fund. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

1 Year
+2.3%
3 Years
+15.8%

Retirement Projection

Based on max. contribution of CHF 7'258/year, age 30 to 65 (35 years), starting from CHF 0.

Projected CapitalCHF 567'034
Total Contributions
CHF 254'030
Estimated Growth
+CHF 313'004
Net Return
4.3% p.a.
Gross: 5%
Fee Impact
-CHF 88'819
Total Fees: 0.71%
Contributions
With Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG
Without fees
Simulate with our 3a CalculatorCustomize your age, contribution & risk profile for a detailed projection.

Compare to Similar Products

Swisscanto BVG 3 Responsible Portfolio 15 RT

Swisscanto BVG 3 Responsible Portfolio 15 RT

Cantonal Bank of Zurich (ZKB)

Visit provider
Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG

Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG

Pilla

Visit provider
Total Cost0.57%
Total Cost0.71%
5Y Performance+3.5%
5Y Performance-
Stocks15%
Stocks20%
Not sure? Compare with alternatives

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is the bank behind Pilla 3a?

Crédit Agricole next bank (Suisse) SA in Geneva holds the assets in custody. The pension foundation is the Liberty 3a foundation in Schwyz, and Pilla itself runs as an app.

How much of Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG is in bonds?

70%. The rest is 20% stocks, 5% real estate and 5% other assets, all in ESG index funds from UBS, Swisscanto, Vanguard and iShares.

Is 0.71% a lot for a 20% equity 3a?

It's a large share of the return. The strategy earned 5.00% a year net over three years, so the 0.71% total cost took about one-eighth of what it earned before fees. On CHF 40'000, it's CHF 284 a year.

How We Rated This Product

Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG was evaluated as a product using our weighted scoring system.

  • All-in annual cost (fund TER + provider fee) (40%)
  • Net returns vs similar-risk funds (45%)
  • Entry and exit fees (5%)
  • Track record (5%)
  • Provider trust: verified direct relationship with GetRates (5%)

Investment funds are scored out of 100: all-in annual cost (40 points), net returns over 5 and 3 years against funds with a similar equity share (45), entry and exit fees (5), track record (5) and provider trust, meaning a verified direct relationship with GetRates (5). A fund without usable returns gets the middle performance score, 17.5 of 35 points. Learn More About Our Methodology

Ratings are updated monthly based on the latest available data. All products are evaluated using the same methodology.

Information may have changed since our last review. Please verify all details directly with the provider before making any decisions.

Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG

3.2/5

Visit provider