Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG

Almost the same three-year return as True Wealth Global 35, at five times the cost.

Overall Rating
2.6/5
Ranked #172 of 201View Top 10
  • Investment Fund (3a)
Adrien Missioux
Written by Adrien Missioux
Last updated on Swiss Made
Pilla
Total Costs
0.72%
Stocks
35%
Investment Strategy
Passively-managed fund
Best For:
moderate savers who want a bond-heavy ESG mix in an app, Pilla users who want a middle step between the 20 and 55 strategies, investors building several portfolios with one provider
Consider Alternatives If:
you'd rather pay 0.14% elsewhere for a similar three-year result, you want a five-year track record, you want costs in proportion to a moderate return expectation
On This Page

Our Take on Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG

Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG ranks #172 among 201 3a investment funds in Switzerland, currently the lowest of Pilla's five strategies. It holds 35% stocks, 55% bonds, 5% real estate and 5% other assets in ESG index funds. It's for moderate savers who want Pilla's app, but the numbers make it a hard sell.

What Are You Actually Paying For?

Total cost is 0.72%: Pilla's 0.50% fee plus a 0.22% fund TER. True Wealth Global 35 costs 0.14% and True Wealth Global 35 SRI 0.17%. On CHF 30'000, Pilla costs CHF 216 a year versus CHF 42 at True Wealth Global 35. Our cost score: 23.1 of 40.

Returns don't make up the gap. Over three years to 30 September 2026, Pilla 35 returned 22.37% net (6.96% a year). True Wealth Global 35 returned 22.68%, True Wealth Global 35 SRI 21.98%. Same risk, same result, very different price.

What Actually Stands Out

The 55% bond allocation is the real feature. It sits between Pilla Selection Index 20 ESG (70% bonds) and Pilla Selection Index 55 ESG (35% bonds), giving moderate savers a middle step. The building blocks are ESG index funds from UBS, Swisscanto, Vanguard and iShares, so the sustainability screen is built in.

Since Pilla allows up to five portfolios, Pilla 35 can serve as the calmer pot next to a growth portfolio. The bank behind it is Crédit Agricole next bank (Suisse) SA in Geneva, and the app is the only way in. Pilla's pillar 3a page shows the full line-up.

What Most Reviews Miss

Here's why it ranks so low: our methodology compares Pilla 35 with all funds holding 30-60% stocks, and many of those hold far more equity. In that group, its three-year return landed in the bottom quarter, worth only a small share of the 45 performance points. A 35% fund rarely shines against 60% funds in a rising market.

On top of that, there's no five-year record in our data, so track record scores 2 of 5. Low performance points, a middling cost score and a short history add up to one of the lower scores in our ranking. The three-year window also starts after 2022, so this bond-heavy mix hasn't been tested by a rate shock in our data.

The Bottom Line

Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG gives a moderate investor exactly what the label says, but True Wealth's 35% strategies have done the same job for a fraction of the price. Pick it only if Pilla's app is a must. Not sure which risk level suits you? Use our 3a product finder.

Verdict: A reasonable moderate ESG mix let down by a fee five times higher than an equally performing rival.

Pros
  • Good 3-year performance (+22.4%)
  • No custody fee
Cons
  • Limited track record (no 5-year data)
  • No swing pricing protection

Product Details

  • 35% stocks allocation
  • TER: 0.22%
  • Passive/Index strategy
  • No custody fee

Fund Details

Investment Strategy
Passively-managed fund
Depositary Bank
Crédit Agricole next bank (Suisse) SA
Swing Pricing
No

Fees & Costs

TER
0.22%
Flat Fee
0.50%
Custody Fee
Free

Asset Allocation

How this fund splits your 3a money across asset classes, as published by the provider.

Stocks 35%Bonds 55%Real Estate 5%Other 5%
35%Stocks
  • Stocks35%
  • Bonds55%
  • Real Estate5%
  • Other5%

Performance Over Time

Historical performance of this investment fund. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

1 Year
+5.9%
3 Years
+22.4%

Retirement Projection

Based on max. contribution of CHF 7'258/year, age 30 to 65 (35 years), starting from CHF 0.

Projected CapitalCHF 851'489
Total Contributions
CHF 254'030
Estimated Growth
+CHF 597'459
Net Return
6.2% p.a.
Gross: 7%
Fee Impact
-CHF 143'317
Total Fees: 0.72%
Contributions
With Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG
Without fees
Simulate with our 3a CalculatorCustomize your age, contribution & risk profile for a detailed projection.

Compare to Similar Products

Tellco Classic – Strategy 45 V

Tellco Classic – Strategy 45 V

Tellco

Visit provider
Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG

Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG

Pilla

Visit provider
Total Cost0.64%
Total Cost0.72%
5Y Performance+6.0%
5Y Performance-
Stocks46%
Stocks35%
Not sure? Compare with alternatives

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG rank so low?

Two things. Its three-year return landed in the bottom quarter of funds with 30-60% stocks, many of which hold more equity, and its 0.72% cost earns 23.1 of 40 cost points. With no five-year data, it also gets just 2 of 5 track-record points.

Is Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG a sustainable 3a?

Yes. It invests only in ESG index funds from UBS, Swisscanto, Vanguard and iShares. The mix is 35% stocks, 55% bonds, 5% real estate and 5% other assets.

What did Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG return over the last year?

Up 5.90% net of fees in the 12 months to 30 September 2026. Over three years it returned 22.37%, or 6.96% a year.

How We Rated This Product

Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG was evaluated as a product using our weighted scoring system.

  • All-in annual cost (fund TER + provider fee) (40%)
  • Net returns vs similar-risk funds (45%)
  • Entry and exit fees (5%)
  • Track record (5%)
  • Provider trust: verified direct relationship with GetRates (5%)

Investment funds are scored out of 100: all-in annual cost (40 points), net returns over 5 and 3 years against funds with a similar equity share (45), entry and exit fees (5), track record (5) and provider trust, meaning a verified direct relationship with GetRates (5). A fund without usable returns gets the middle performance score, 17.5 of 35 points. Learn More About Our Methodology

Ratings are updated monthly based on the latest available data. All products are evaluated using the same methodology.

Information may have changed since our last review. Please verify all details directly with the provider before making any decisions.

Pilla Selection Index 35 ESG

2.6/5

Visit provider