Pilla Selection Index 75 ESG ranks #138 among 201 3a investment funds in Switzerland. It holds 75% stocks, 15% bonds, 5% real estate and 5% other assets, all in ESG index funds. It's for growth-minded investors who still want a small bond slice and value Pilla's app and multi-portfolio setup more than a rock-bottom fee.
Are the Fees Worth It?
Total cost is 0.73%: Pilla's 0.50% fee plus a 0.23% fund TER. On CHF 60'000, that's CHF 438 a year. At a similar risk level, frankly Strong 75 Index costs 0.48%, frankly Strong 75 Sustainable 0.43% and Swissquote 3a Dynamic 0.60%. Among digital providers at this risk level, Pilla is on the expensive side.
Returns are middle of the pack. Over three years to 30 September 2026 it returned 40.62% net (12.03% a year), close to the median of funds with 60-85% stocks. frankly Strong 75 Sustainable returned 42.84% and Swissquote 3a Dynamic 38.64%. Paying more hasn't bought extra performance.
What Actually Stands Out
You can run up to five separate portfolios in the Pilla app. You could hold this 75% strategy for the long run and a more defensive Pilla strategy for money you'll need first. Whether each portfolio can be withdrawn on its own date is worth confirming with Pilla before you plan around it.
The building blocks are ESG index funds from UBS, Swisscanto, Vanguard and iShares, held at Crédit Agricole next bank (Suisse) SA in Geneva, with the Liberty 3a foundation in Schwyz. The 3a rules every provider follows are set at federal level by the Federal Social Insurance Office.
What Most Reviews Miss
Our ranking only has three years of returns for this strategy. That limits track record to 2 of 5 points and caps performance at 85% of 45. Pilla 75's mid-table result keeps it well below that cap, so the short history isn't what holds it back. The 0.73% cost is: it earns just 22.8 of 40 cost points.
With 15% bonds and 5% real estate, the cushion is thin. The three-year window starts after 2022, so the 40.62% figure comes from a mostly rising market. Expect a meaningful drawdown in a bad year and size your position accordingly.
The Bottom Line
Pilla Selection Index 75 ESG is a solid growth portfolio with average three-year returns and above-average costs. Its multi-portfolio setup is the real reason to pick it. If you're thinking about splitting your 3a, our guide on holding multiple 3a accounts explains the strategy.
Verdict: A sensible 75% equity ESG mix whose main edge is flexibility, not cost or returns.
