VZ Pillar 3a Index Investments 45 ranks #162 among 201 3a investment funds in Switzerland. It's one of VZ VermögensZentrum's moderate strategies, with 45% in stocks and the rest in fixed income, real estate, commodities and specialities. It suits cautious mid-career savers who want an advised 3a with a balanced, index-based mix.
What Does 0.83% Cost You?
VZ's 0.68% management fee plus about 0.15% in fund costs gives roughly 0.83% all-in. On CHF 100'000 that's CHF 830 a year. neon Balanced 45 costs 0.42%, or CHF 420 on the same balance.
The closest like-for-like is relevate dynamic, also 45% stocks, at 0.52%. It ranks far higher and has returned 17.90% over five years after fees. VZ's 45% strategy has no verified return in our data, so you can't make that comparison yet.
What Actually Stands Out
There are no entry or exit fees: issue and redemption costs are covered by the 0.68% fee, which earns the full 5 points in our methodology. Rebalancing is free too, so the 45% target is maintained without extra charges.
It also beats several bank funds on price: Valiant Helvetique Balanced V costs 1.16% and Raiffeisen Futura Pension Invest Balanced V 1.10%. VZ describes the range on its 3a index investments page.
What Most Reviews Miss
Its score includes 0 of 5 for track record and a neutral 22.5 of 45 for performance. We don't have verified net returns, and the ranking won't guess. That's fair, but it leaves you investing on trust.
A moderate mix also feels fees more. On a portfolio that's more than half bonds and other assets, 0.83% a year takes a bigger share of the expected return than it would in a 97% equity fund.
The Bottom Line
VZ Pillar 3a Index Investments 45 is cheaper than many bank balanced funds, but digital rivals at the same equity share cost much less and show real returns. Run your own numbers in our Pillar 3a calculator to see what a 0.3 to 0.4 point fee gap does over 20 years.
Verdict: A reasonable moderate index strategy for VZ clients, but relevate dynamic and neon Balanced 45 offer more for less.