VZ Pillar 3a Index Investments 60 ranks #161 among 201 3a investment funds in Switzerland. It's VZ VermögensZentrum's balanced option, with 60% in stocks, built from ETFs and index funds. It suits savers who want a classic balanced 3a inside an advisory relationship, but the ranking shows what that convenience costs.
Why Does It Rank So Low?
The score is built from 19.9 of 40 for cost, a neutral 22.5 of 45 for performance, 0 of 5 for track record, 5 of 5 for having no entry or exit fees, and 2 of 5 for provider trust. That adds up to a low overall score.
The cost is the biggest measurable drag. VZ's 0.68% management fee plus roughly 0.15% in fund costs comes to about 0.83% a year. True Wealth Global 60, one of our top-ranked funds, costs 0.15%. On CHF 50'000 that's CHF 415 versus CHF 75, a CHF 340 gap every year.
What Actually Stands Out
The building blocks are ETFs and index funds, not active managers, and VZ's fee already covers trading, issue and redemption costs and custody. You won't get surprise charges when the portfolio is rebalanced, which happens at no extra cost.
Foreign-currency exposure is capped at 60%, so a balanced investor keeps a solid Swiss-franc base. VZ explains the six strategies on its 3a index investments page.
What Most Reviews Miss
Without verified net returns, there's no way to tell from our data whether VZ's portfolio construction makes up for the higher fee. For comparison, finpension Global 60 at 0.39% shows 31.42% over three years, and Yuh 3a Spicy (60) at 0.50% shows 34.22%.
Also, the roughly 0.15% fund cost is VZ's own estimate rather than a fixed number, so the real all-in figure can move. Check the latest factsheet before you compare.
The Bottom Line
VZ Pillar 3a Index Investments 60 is a clean balanced index mix, but it costs far more than the funds at the top of our ranking and shows no track record. If you're unsure which provider fits your situation, our 3a product finder narrows the field in a few questions.
Verdict: A sensible 60% equity strategy in an advisory setting, but at 0.83% all-in it's outclassed by cheaper balanced funds.