Pilla Selection Index 95 ESG ranks #134 among 201 3a investment funds in Switzerland. It's Pilla's growth option: 95% stocks and 5% other assets in ESG index funds, with no bonds. It's for long-horizon investors who want a near-all-equity 3a from a bank-backed app and accept a fee above the cheapest digital providers.
Are the Fees Worth It?
The fund TER here is 0.18%, the lowest in the Pilla line-up, so the total with Pilla's 0.50% fee is 0.68%. On CHF 80'000, that's CHF 544 a year. frankly Extreme 95 Index costs 0.46% (CHF 368), and frankly Extreme 95 Sustainable 0.43%. Our cost score: 24.3 of 40.
Over three years to 30 September 2026, it returned 48.76% net (14.16% a year), right around the middle of funds with 85-100% stocks. frankly Extreme 95 Index returned 51.50% and Yuh 3a Fiery 50.09%. So you pay more than for either and have received slightly less.
What Actually Stands Out
It's the purest equity play Pilla offers: 95% stocks, 0% bonds, 0% real estate. Holdings come from ESG index funds by UBS, Swisscanto, Vanguard and iShares. Over the past year it returned 19.13%, the highest one-year figure of the five Pilla strategies.
Custody sits with Crédit Agricole next bank (Suisse) SA in Geneva, a Swiss bank you can look up in FINMA's register. The pension foundation is the Liberty 3a foundation in Schwyz. You can hold up to five portfolios, so this strategy can sit next to a calmer one.
What Most Reviews Miss
Without five-year data, the three-year window is all you get, and it starts after the 2022 crash. Our data hasn't shown this exact portfolio in a bear market yet. The methodology reflects that: 2 of 5 track-record points and performance capped at 85% of 45 points. Pilla 95's mid-table result keeps it well below the cap.
The lower TER doesn't change the main picture: Pilla's own 0.50% fee is the bulk of what you pay. Over 20 years, the 0.22-point gap to frankly Extreme 95 Index adds up to roughly CHF 3'500 on a steady CHF 80'000 balance, before any compounding.
The Bottom Line
Pilla Selection Index 95 ESG is a decent all-equity ESG portfolio with middling three-year returns and above-average costs. It makes sense if you want Pilla's app and its mix of fund houses. Before committing, put it next to cheaper equity strategies with our 3a comparison tool.
Verdict: A sustainable 95% equity 3a with respectable returns, priced above comparable digital alternatives.
